The first thing we ask anyone who says they want a lightsaber is whether they're going to duel with it or put it on a shelf. Everything else follows from that answer, so settle it before you fall for a hilt.
The mistake we see most is buying a display saber and then deciding you want to duel with it. Do it in the other order and you're fine. Here's the short list.
If you want to duel, get the Practitioner in Baselit
The Practitioner is our own design, with no movie character behind it, and in Baselit it's $109. Baselit is the electronics we build for impact. It has a 10.6 inch hilt, a polycarbonate blade in 32 or 36 inches, a rechargeable battery, and five hilt colors. If a friend asks what to buy with about $150 to spend, this is the answer.
If you're buying for a kid, same answer
It's the one we'd start a kid on. We don't publish a numeric age rating, so you're the best judge of whether your kid is ready. The toy vs hobby post and the gift guide cover that decision. The Sidekick in our Lightsabers for Kids collection starts at $99 and is described as lightweight and made for younger users.
If you mostly want it on a shelf and love a character, pick the character first
Then pick Neopixel or Proffie. Neopixel suits display and light contact, and the Neopixel guide explains why. A Vader is the obvious example, and our Vader lightsaber post compares it with Anakin's. The Darth Vader EP5 in Neopixel is $419.
If you want to tinker with sounds and effects, get Proffie
Proffie is a soundboard that lets you customize colors, sound fonts and effects. The Proffie explainer has the details before you commit to the higher price.
If you want the look of a character and might duel someday, buy Baselit now
This is where people get burned. Some character-inspired models come in Baselit, like the Darth Vader EP5 SE and the Windu SE, both from $199. Pick the electronics before you fall for the hilt, and you keep the option to swing it.
Still stuck? Every saber has a 60-day return window and lifetime support, so a wrong guess is fixable. The dueling guide goes deeper on the Baselit vs Neopixel choice.
We aren't affiliated with Lucasfilm or Disney, and our character-inspired sabers are our own designs, not official products.